The Annunciation

The earliest evidence for a March 25 Annunciation feast comes from sixth-century Constantinople (c. 555, under Justinian I). In the Latin West, the Sacramentary of Pope Gelasius (d. 496) and the Sacramentary of Pope Gregory (d. 604) mention it, though scholars debate whether the feast originated in their time or later. The first certain reference is the 656 Council of Toledo, which describes the feast as 'celebrated throughout the church.' The Spanish Church initially observed the Annunciation on December 18 rather than March 25, and the tenth Synod of Toledo (656) confirmed this local usage.

The Quinisext Council (Constantinople, 692) allowed the Annunciation as an exception to the rule against feast days during Lent — a concession reflecting the feast's importance and the practical tension between its fixed March 25 date and the moveable Lenten calendar. Modern Western practice transfers the feast when it falls in Holy Week or Easter Week.

The relationship between March 25 and December 25 is fundamental. The Calculation Hypothesis holds that early Christians identified March 25 as both the date of Christ's death and his conception (following a Jewish tradition that great persons die on the date of their conception or birth). Nine months from March 25 yields December 25. Whether the Annunciation date generated the Christmas date or vice versa remains debated, but the theological logic is clear: the Incarnation is a single mystery whose beginning (conception) and manifestation (birth) are intimately linked.

In England, March 25 was known as Lady Day and served as the legal New Year from 1155 to 1752, when the Gregorian calendar moved the new year to January 1. Lady Day was the first of four English Quarter Days (with Midsummer, Michaelmas, and Christmas), marking when agricultural contracts began and rents were due. The theological symbolism was intentional: the year began where the story of salvation began, with the Word becoming flesh.

Irenaeus of Lyons (c. 180) developed the foundational New Eve theology: 'The knot of Eve's disobedience was untied by Mary's obedience.' Just as death entered through a woman's 'no' to God's design, salvation entered through a woman's 'yes.' This patristic theme — Mary as the faithful counterpart to faithless Eve — became central to Christian reflection on the Annunciation across all traditions.

John Donne was born in 1572 into a prominent Catholic family during the Elizabethan penal period. His mother was descended from the More family (John More's niece); his uncle was a Jesuit missionary. This Catholic inheritance—intellectual, spiritual, and dangerous—shaped his entire life. He was educated at Hart Hall, Oxford, and Lincoln's Inn, London, studying law and languages. In his youth he was a courtier, wit, and writer of erotic poetry (songs, satires) that circulated in manuscript among the literary elite.

At age nineteen he may have secretly married Ann More, ward of Sir George More; the marriage was acknowledged around 1601 and sundered his legal prospects. His most productive years (1600s–1610s) saw him in poverty and professional limbo, dependent on patronage. During this period he composed many of his Holy Sonnets (c. 1609–1611)—wrestling with faith, guilt, sexuality, and death—and his metaphysical love poetry.

In 1610 he published Pseudodoxia (a theological treatise) and began to secure patronage. A turning point came in 1615 when, at age forty-two and in financial desperation, he sought ordination in the Church of England. King James I, impressed by Donne's learning, encouraged him. He was ordained and rapidly rose in the Church: appointed chaplain to the king, then (1621) Dean of St. Paul's, one of the most prestigious ecclesiastical posts in England.

As dean (1621–1631), Donne preached an estimated 160 sermons, many surviving in print. These sermons—delivered from the famous Paul's Cross pulpit and in the Cathedral—combined learning (biblical, patristic, legal), innovation (vivid imagery, dramatic rhetoric), and theological depth. In 1624, seriously ill, he wrote his Devotions Upon Emergent Occasions, a sequence of twenty-three meditations, expostulations, and prayers following the course of a grave fever. This work, published posthumously in 1624, stands with the Preces Privatae as a masterpiece of Stuart devotional literature. Donne died on March 31, 1631, and was buried in St. Paul's; his last sermon, 'Death's Duel,' was preached the month before his death.

Donne had no medieval cult or formal canonization. His reputation rested entirely on his literary achievement and preaching fame during his lifetime. After his death, his works went through cycles of recovery and eclipse. The seventeenth and eighteenth centuries valued his sermons more than his poetry; the poetry was largely forgotten until nineteenth-century revival (T.S. Eliot's 1921 essays on metaphysical poetry resurrected Donne's literary reputation). Modern Anglo-Catholicism reclaimed him as a figure of integration—poet-priest, wit and saint, passionate and learned. His Devotions has been continuously reprinted and remains a standard spiritual text. His inclusion in Anglican calendars dates to nineteenth-century revival of saint commemoration and reflects modern rather than unbroken tradition. The Holy Sonnets, published posthumously (1633) and long attributed to his youth, are now recognized as written in middle age during spiritual crisis, making them central to understanding his conversion and faith.